
When I was 25 and in seminary I had a very wise friend named Neil tell me to enjoy being 25 because "that is the coolest I will ever be in my life". I laughed at him, but got a little nervous at the same time. I wondered what that meant, do I have to leave student ministry, was I going to lose my relevance, was I going to get replaced by a younger cooler model? These are the questions I wrestled with.
After a week of thinking about it, worrying about it, I decided to bring the Yoda in my life into the discussion....my wife. I asked her "babe, do you think I'm cool". Se said "no, you are a dork". Not exactly what I wanted to hear. We laughed and I went on to tell her what Neil said, and ask her what that meant to her. She said "I don't know you tell me". You can see where this conversation was going, not very helpful. She could see I was uneasy and reminded me of the great adult leaders, and how students loved them, how I thought like a student still, and said she was sure we'd be fine. I felt frustrated that i didn't get the "you are and always will be the coolest man next to Jonny Depp" and agreed with her but didn't know why I was so uneasy.
When I went back to Neil I shared what I was going through with his silly comment (the funny thing is he was 10 years older than me and still a great youth pastor). Through our conversation he asked a valuable question. One that I will never forget and I keep asking everyday. He said "what is your ministry built on"? He went on to describe how many student ministries are built on the personality and coolness of the youth pastor. He talked about how many youth pastors ride the coolness factor and through the coolness of who they are the ministry grows, students bring friends, and what seems like ministry success happens.
Then he dropped the bomb, "most of those people I know like that didn't make it to 30 in ministry". He illustrated that life after cool is different and a ministry built on the cool leader shrinks when the leader stops being cool, and decreasing coolness is as sure a thing as Apple releasing a new iPod every year.
"But I don't want to be an adult pastor, with all the collared shirts, no flip flops, will have to grow a mustache/goatee combo, throw out my video games" I said half meaning all of it, and he laughed. I realized that day I can only go so far on personality and talent alone. If I don't have substance, if I am not growing, if I am not deeper than just personality then I'm doomed. Neil looked me in the eyes, I think he could sense my worry and discouragement thinking this was my last good year of youth ministry, and said "Mike, that is why you went to seminary. To get substance to bring to your students. As long as you love students and continue to grow you will be fine".
I really believe that day saved my ministry. That is a day that saved me from flaming out, from doubting my calling when I was no longer the cool pastor (and I definitely am not the cool pastor now and it's debatable if there was ever a moment I was the cool pastor). That was the day I realized I could be 50 and great at student ministry because I had depth. So I will ask you the same question, "what is your ministry built on"? Is it personality, or have you committed yourself to loving God, Students, and bringing depth to your ministry? I want us to make it past the cool.